Review:
They Say I Say: The Moves That Matter In Academic Writing By Gerald Graff And Cathy Birkenstein
overall review score: 4.5
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
score is between 0 and 5
They Say / I Say: The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing by Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein is a influential guidebook designed to help students and writers craft compelling and persuasive academic arguments. It emphasizes the importance of rhetorical moves, such as summarizing others’ viewpoints, responding with agreement or disagreement, and making your own position clear. The book provides templates and practical strategies to develop effective writing skills within academic contexts, aiming to foster critical thinking and confident participation in scholarly conversations.
Key Features
- Emphasis on rhetorical moves that are central to academic writing
- Practical templates for structuring arguments and responses
- Focus on engaging with sources effectively through 'they say / I say' frameworks
- Accessible language suitable for both students and educators
- Includes real-world examples and exercises to reinforce learning
Pros
- Clear, practical guidance for developing strong academic arguments
- Effective use of templates makes complex ideas accessible
- Encourages critical engagement with sources
- Widely used in educational settings, enhancing teaching methods
- Supports students in becoming confident writers
Cons
- Focuses primarily on rhetoric, which may oversimplify complex writing processes
- Some readers may find the templates limiting if overused
- Less emphasis on stylistic nuances or creative writing aspects
- Can feel formulaic if applied rigidly without understanding context